Illegal mining · Market design
For a Fistful of Gold (Job Market Paper)
Abstract
By empowering conflicts, deforestation and intimidation of the legal economy, illegal mining of gold constitutes a challenging puzzle for policymakers. Because provenance is only a claim, it enters the global market avoiding regulation. In this paper, I study how trade resists policy efforts to stop it and I develop a blockchain-based certification aimed at hindering it. To model its resilience, I model a coerced jungle economy in which an armed group controls the sale of both the inputs and outputs. The trade powers through a policy shock because of households' required subsistence level of wealth. The intermediary can recover margins both by adjusting prices in the jungle and by re-allocating the metal via its selling mechanism. I evidence the re-allocation by looking at the receipts following the policy-driven demand shock. These generate a price effect on regulated bids which transmits imperfectly, and up to a ceiling, to receipts due to laundering and the level of competing bids. Blockchain breaks the cycle by ensuring provenance up to a minting node; leaking out of a legal mine becomes impossible. Leakage at the mine level is looked at through the lens of contracting and auditing which determine the blockchain's credibility. At the macro level, the blockchain segmentation breaks the pooling of innovation and allows for public funding of a clean mining industry. At the micro level, it changes incentives in affected countries to take back control of their jungle to fund a legal mining industry. Macro and micro work as scissors to stop the illegal mining industry.
